It’s Post Time by Jon White: Undefeated Maximus Mischief Wins Remsen

Is Maximus Mischief another Smarty Jones?

Smarty Jones won his first two career starts as a 2-year-old in 2003, both at Philadelphia Park, the track now known as Parx Racing. He won those races by 7 3/4 and 15 lengths. Smarty Jones then made it three for three with a victory at Aqueduct. He took the Count Fleet Stakes at the Big A early in 2004 on Jan. 3.

Maximus Mischief won his first two career starts as a 2-year-old in 2018, both at Parx Racing. He won those races 8 3/4 and six lengths. Maximus Mischief then made it three for three with a victory at Aqueduct. He took the Grade II Remsen Stakes at the Big A last Saturday.

After Maximus Mischief’s maiden victory at 5 1/2 furlongs on Sept. 29 at Parx, Dick Jerardi told Daily Racing Form’s Jay Privman that this was the best horse from Parx since Smarty Jones. Jerardi knows his stuff. An award-winning turf writer, Jerardi is a member of the team that calculates Beyer Speed Figures.

After the 2003 Count Fleet, Smarty Jones kept his unbeaten record intact by reeling off three consecutive wins at Oaklawn Park. He took the Southwest Stakes, Rebel Stakes and Grade II Arkansas Derby. Smarty Jones then stayed unbeaten by capturing the Grade I Kentucky Derby at Churchill Downs and Grade I Preakness Stakes at Pimlico. He finally lost for the first — and only — time when thwarted in his bid for a Triple Crown sweep. He finished second, one length behind Birdstone, in the Grade I Belmont Stakes at Belmont Park.

The “Smarty party,” as it became to be known, came to an end after the June 5 Belmont Stakes, which turned out to be the colt’s final race. On Aug. 2, Smarty Jones’ retirement was announced. It was reported that the Kentucky-bred son of Elusive Quality would not race again and go to stud due to chronic bruising of his ankle bones.

Trained by John Servis, Smarty Jones was voted a 2014 Eclipse Award as champion 3-year-old male.

Will Maximus Mischief be like Smarty Jones and go on to win the Kentucky Derby and/or Preakness? As they say, time will tell.

The bad news for Maximus Mischief vis-a-vis the Kentucky Derby is that it’s been a long time since a Remsen winner also has won the Run for the Roses. The last horse to win both races was Thunder Gulch, who took the Remsen in 1994 and Kentucky Derby in 1995.

Catholic Boy this year made it 23 consecutive Remsen winners who did not subsequently succeed in the Kentucky Derby. However, Catholic Boy did have a fine 2018 campaign, highlighted by victories in the Grade I Belmont Derby on the grass and Grade I Travers Stakes on the dirt at Saratoga.

Regardless of what the future holds for Maximus Mischief, he did prove a lot in the Remsen. The bay colt demonstrated that he:

–Can win on a surface other than Parx’s main track.

–Has the class to win at the Grade II level. This was his stakes debut.

–Possesses the stamina to win a 1 1/8-mile contest around two turns. His two races at Parx were going seven furlongs or shorter around one turn.

Ridden by Frankie Pennington and trained by Butch Reid, Maximus Mischief balked at going into the gate for the Remsen, but he then started “beautifully,” as noted by track announcer Frank Mirahmadi.

“For a big horse, he’s light on his feet and springs out of the gate well,” Reid said Monday morning to Steve Byk on his radio program At The Races

Reid added that the Kentucky-bred colt “is a good athlete.”

After Maximus Mischief’s alert start, he raced on or just off the lead the entire way. The fractions through the first six furlongs were :25.12, :50.67 and 1:14.60. Coming into the stretch, Maximus Mischief found himself battling for command with Tax.

Maximus Mischief put away Tax to have a 2 1/2-length lead at the furlong marker, then kept to his task in the final furlong to prevail by 2 3/4 lengths as the 7-5 second favorite. Network Effect, the betting choice at a bit over even money, came home willingly to finish second in the field of seven. Tax ended up third, a half-length behind Network Effect.

Completing his journey in 1:51.34, Maximus Mischief was credited with a 97 Beyer Speed Figure. It should be noted that whether or not he does come anywhere close to accomplishing what Smarty Jones did at 3, Maximus Mischief’s 97 Beyer in the Remsen is the best figure by a Remsen winner in the last six years.

These are the Beyers for winners of the Remsen going back to 1991:

2018 Maximus Mischief (97)

2017 Catholic Boy (91)

2016 Mo Town (86)

2015 Mohaymen (95)

2014 Leave the Light On (90)

2013 Honor Code (88)

2012 Overanalyze (99)

2011 O’Prado Again (80)

2010 To Honor and Serve (102)

2009 Buddy’s Saint (82)

2008 Old Fashioned (100)

2007 Court Vision (76)

2006 Nobiz Like Shobiz (97)

2005 Bluegrass Cat (95)

2004 Rockport Harbor (102)

2003 Read the Footnotes (105)

2002 Toccet (101)

2001 Saarland (87)

2000 Windsor Castle (92)

1999 Greenwood Lake (91)

1998 Comeonmom (94)

1997 Coronado’s Quest (91)

1996 The Silver Move (91)

1995 Tropicool (94)

1994 Thunder Gulch (89)

1993 Go for Gin (95)

1992 Silver of Silver (96)

1991 Pine Bluff (93)

Following Maximus Mischief’s Remsen victory, he returned to Parx Saturday evening. According to Reid, the colt emerged from the race “perfectly.” In NYRA communications’ Aqueduct notes, Reid said Sunday that Maximus Mischief was a little tired after the race, “but he’s on his toes this morning.”

Reid especially liked Maximus Mischief’s demeanor before the race.

“The most impressive part was how he acted in the paddock and all the prerace stuff,” Reid said, “because he can be a handful in the paddock. In his new surroundings, he handled it very well. He stood perfectly in the paddock, which at Aqueduct can be a little foreboding. He handled it great and was cool as a cucumber. He stood there perfectly when we put the tack on him. I was pretty confident with the way things were going after that.”

Whereas Smarty Jones went the Arkansas route to the Kentucky Derby, Maximus Mischief is scheduled to race probably twice at Gulfstream Park prior to the big race at Churchill Downs on the first Saturday in May.

“We’re going to give him a little break, but then we’ll be heading down to Florida in the next few weeks,” Reid said. “We’ll get him used to the weather down there and get him ready to start his 3-year-old campaign.”

Reid told the DRF’s David Grening that the plan is for Maximus Mischief to likely run in either the Grade II Holy Bull Stakes Feb. 2 or Grade II Fountain of Youth Stakes on March 2 prior to the Grade I Florida Derby on March 30.


Despite the Kentucky Derby drought by Remsen winners, those who bet on Maximus Mischief at 26-1 in Pool One of the 2019 Kentucky Derby Future Wager (KDFW) on Nov. 25 no doubt were pleased to see the colt run so well last Saturday.

Here were the final odds for Pool One of the 2019 KDFW:

6-5 All Other 3-Year-Old Males

5-1 Game Winner

10-1 Coliseum

10-1 Instagrand

17-1 Improbable

18-1 Code of Honor

26-1 Maximus Mischief

30-1 Signalman

32-1 Roadster

36-1 Vekoma

43-1 Magic On Tap

44-1 Knicks Go

44-1 Mucho

46-1 Tale of the Union

47-1 Mucho Gusto

53-1 King for a Day

53-1 Uncle Benny

59-1 Cairo Cat

59-1 Network Effect

66-1 All 3-Year-Old Fillies

72-1 Dunph

76-1 Gunmetal Gray

88-1 Epic Dreamer

117-1 Preamble

Meanwhile, another consequence of Maximus Mischief’s Remsen triumph is it likely brought a smile to those who bet on his sire at 7-1 in the 2019 Kentucky Derby Sire Future Wager. Maximus Mischief is by Into Mischief.

Into Mischief also is the sire of Instagrand, who won both of his starts impressively during the summer in Southern California. He cruised to a 10-length victory in a five-furlong maiden special weight race at Los Alamitos on June 29 in his debut. He then won Del Mar’s Grade II Best Pal Stakes by 10 1/4 lengths at six furlongs on Aug. 11.

After the Best Pal, it was decided that Instagrand would not race again in 2018. He was sent to Kentucky to take it easy for the rest of the year. The Kentucky-bred Into Mischief colt, who sold for $1.2 million at public auction last March, now is back in training with Hall of Famer Jerry Hollendorfer at Santa Anita.

When Justify took the 2018 Kentucky Derby as the favorite, he paid $7.80 for a $2 win ticket. Justify returned just $4.40 as part of the “All Other 3-Year-Olds” option in Pool One of the 2018 KDFW. But a bet on Justify’s sire, Scat Daddy, paid $54.80 in the Kentucky Derby Sire Future Wager.

Here were the final odds on Nov. 25 for the 2019 Kentucky Derby Sire Future Wager:

9-2 All Other Sires

6-1 Tapit

7-1 Candy Ride

7-1 Into Mischief

13-1 Curlin

17-1 City Zip

20-1 Quality Road

21-1 Medaglia d’Oro

23-1 Uncle Mo

24-1 Bernardini

24-1 Pioneerof the Nile

27-1 Ghostzapper

27-1 Scat Daddy

28-1 Orb

29-1 Union Rags

30-1 Cairo Prince

40-1 Will Take Charge

41-1 War Front

47-1 Violence

47-1 Giant’s Causeway

48-1 More Than Ready

49-1 Malibu Moon

50-1 Tiznow

59-1 Speightstown

Tapit is the sire of Coliseum and Magic On Tap, a pair of youngsters trained by Bob Baffert.

Coliseum raised eyebrows when he won a seven-furlong maiden special weight race by 6 3/4 lengths on Nov. 17 at Del Mar in his only start so far. He had a splendid workout Tuesday morning at Santa Anita, a bullet four furlongs in :47.00, fastest of 82 at the distance.

Magic On Tap won a 6 1/2-furlong maiden special weight race by 2 1/2 lengths on Sept. 1 at Del Mar. That has been his lone start to date.

Candy Ride is the sire of undefeated Game Winner. Also conditioned by Baffert, Game Winner is a three-time Grade I winner this year (Del Mar Futurity, American Pharoah Stakes at Santa Anita, Breeders’ Cup Juvenile at Churchill Downs). Game Winner is odds-on to be voted a 2018 Eclipse Award as champion 2-year-old male.

Vekoma, two for two, is another prominent Candy Ride colt. He won Aqueduct’s Grade III Nashua Stakes by 1 3/4 lengths at one mile on Nov. 4 for trainer George Weaver. The runner-up in the Nashua was Network Effect, who then also finished second in last Saturday’s Remsen.


Hall of Famer Baffert appears to have an excellent chance to win yet another Los Alamitos CashCall Futurity this Saturday. He sends out Improbable, who is two for two, and Mucho Gusto, likewise two for two, in the Grade I race that will be contested at 1 1/16 miles.

Improbable, a Kentucky-bred City Zip colt, is coming off a sparkling 7 1/4-length win in the one-mile Street Sense Stakes at Churchill Downs on Nov. 7. He recorded a sharp workout Monday at Santa Anita, five furlongs in a bullet :59.80, fastest of 67 at the distance.

Mucho Gusto, a Kentucky-bred Mucho Macho Man colt, recently won Del Mar’s seven-furlong Bob Hope Stakes by 1 1/2 lengths on Nov. 17.

The Los Alamitos CashCall Futurity, formerly the Hollywood Futurity, was run at Hollywood Park from 1981 through 2013. Baffert has won this race a record 10 times, including all editions at Los Alamitos from 2014 through 2017.

Here is the list of Baffert’s 10 Los Al Futurity winners:

1997 Real Quiet

1999 Captain Steve

2000 Point Given

2008 Pioneerof the Nile

2009 Lookin At Lucky

2011 Liaison

2014 Dortmund

2015 Mor Spirit

2016 Mastery

2017 McKinzie

I will be surprised if someone other than Improbable wins Saturday.

It’s Post Time by Jon White: Undefeated Maximus Mischief Wins Remsen

It’s Post Time by Jon White |